The Bellinghman (bellinghman) wrote,
The Bellinghman

#36 Alexander McCall Smith: 44 Scotland Street

Alexander McCall Smith: 44 Scotland Street

Paperback: 336 pages
Publisher: Abacus (11 Aug 2005)
ISBN-10: 0349118973
Category(ies): General fiction

McCall Smith is probably most famous for his Southern African No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency novels. However, he is an Edinburgh-based novelist who does sometimes write about his own culture. This novel is one of those.

Perhaps the most alarming thing about this book is his introduction, wherein he explains that he originally wrote it as a newspaper serial, a chunk each day. This means that it is built from chapters that are all quite short (perhaps 4 pages), leading to an effect where the texture can never really change. (In the culinary world, this is analogous to taking a steak and mincing it up fine for easier digestion - yes, this is almost a hamburger novel.) However, despite this, it does eventually work.

The novel is based in a block in Edinburgh. (A quick check with Streetmap shows it to be just north of the centre of that city, and supposedly a delightful area to live, only a few blocks from the art galleries, the castle and the botanic garden.) Our heroine is a gap year student (second gap year), who takes a room in a shared flat, while working in a nearby gallery. Other characters are the others who live in the same building, especially her narcissistic flatmate, their employees and associates, and briefly the novelist Ian Rankin (who I think we may assume was cameoed here by McCall Smith as a nod to a friend). Most of the humour arises from character observation, especially the self-absorbed Bruce and the pushy mother Irene who is wondering why her 5-year-old son seems to be resenting the Italian courses and Saxophone lessons.

The story is lightweight - there is no real room to develop anything deep in a format that requires daily advance. But it is a charming, though inconsequential, read
Tags: books, reviews

  • Hugo novels

    So I've worked my way through the novel shortlist, and I've a pretty good idea that I will be actually marking 'No Award' above one particular book.…

  • Retromancer

    I finished reading Robert Rankin's latest pbb last night, and was amused at the Tuckerisation of lproven, but also by the presence of a…

  • Planet 51

    We went off to the cinema yesterday afternoon to see this rather engaging animated feature. Annoyingly, since 'it's a cartoon', and the latest…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded