The Bellinghman (bellinghman) wrote,
The Bellinghman

Why the Swingometer needs to be retired

Look at the following table:

Oliver HealdConservative26,99553.5  +5.5
Hugh AnnandLiberal Democrat11,80123.4 +3.1
David KirkmanLabour8,29116.4-11.9
Adrianne SmythUK Independence Party2,0754.1 +0.8
Rosemary BlandGreen8751.7 +1.7
Richard CampbellIndependent2090.4 +0.4
David RalphYour Right To Democracy Party Limited1430.3 +0.3
Philip ReichardtIndependent360.1 +0.1

Yes, this is a case where the leading candidate increased his vote, the former second place collapsed into third place, and the previous third place rose to second place.

So how does the Swingometer report this multifaceted situation?

A 1.2% swing from LD to CON.

So how is this calculated?

It's half the difference in the winning party's change in vote and the second party's change in vote. In the case where two main parties contest a constituency, if the winner has a vote rise of 5%, and the loser has a loss of 4% (with the rest disappearing off to the marginal parties), then the difference is 9%, and the swing is 4.5%. This is a reasonably meaningful measure, giving some indication of the proportion of voters deserting one party for the other.

But what we have here is not a two party fight, but more a three party one. Both first and second place parties increased their vote. So although the calculation is (5.5% - 3.1%)/2, giving that 1.2%, the implication of the calculated swing that 1.2% of voters deserted the LDs for the Tories is quite blatantly false.
Tags: politics, rants, statistics

  • The prodigal returns

    When we don't see one of the cats of the evening, we don't particularly worry. They'll usually be there for breakfast. Occasionally, they're not…

  • Cats

    There we were last night. We'd watched Dr Who and were watching QI. About ten minutes in, we heard a cat yowling. Now there are a lot of different…

  • Kitties

    For those who follow me, but not bellinghwoman, here is her set of pictures of the Kitties Last night (their second with us) we gave…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment