Log in

No account? Create an account
Off in the distance
my journal
May 2016

The Bellinghman
Date: 2008-02-16 00:23
Subject: #234 Charles Stross: Halting State
Security: Public
Tags:books, books by friends, reviews
Charles Stross: Halting State

Paperback: 352 pages
Publisher: Orbit (24 Jan 2008)
ISBN-10: 1841496944
ISBN-13: 978-1841496948
Category(ies): SF

If there's an author out there who can mix fast story with a torrent of ideas, it's Charles Stross. And unlike many authors, he's not particularly a series writer (the Laundry and Merchant Princes books aside, and the latter is more one long story broken into manageable chunks).

So, here we have a standalone novel, set in a future that (excluding actual Scottish independence) is almost on top of us right now. It's ... hmm, 2018? Sgt. Sue Smith of the Edinburgh Constabulary has been called out to the scene of a bank robbery, but unfortunately for her skill set, it turns out to be a robbery inside an MMORG. And we encounter Elaine (a forensic accountant sent in by investors to try to uncover where the loot went (after all, it has real value)), and Jack (a game coder who has just been made redundant, and is hired as a 'native guide'). Of course, given that the ownership of items in the game is managed using highly encrypted and redundant keys running on computing swarms, the ability to actually reassign items has certain wider implications that only slowly percolate through.

All three of these we encounter in second person singular present tense (though it's an incredible discipline, and there are the odd places where a past tense creeps into the middle of this (p114 if anyone is making corrections)). This brings an immediacy to the story that could have gone seriously wrong, but doesn't. This book demands freshness, because it's almost certainly going to look daft within a decade - that's the danger that books set so close to the present that aren't in the present are subject to. (Just think of all those cold-war thrillers published as the Berlin Wall went down - that's the danger of the near future.) On the other hand, it does show some possible ways that current trends may lead, making predictions that are relevant to the here and now, because they're in planning range. Few writers are brave enough to attempt it, because it requires genuine research, and scads of it, rather than invention or turning to the common consensuses of how the future will be a few hundred years hence.

(A prediction that doesn't come true isn't necessarily a failure - it can have been a warning that was heeded.)

Oh yes, there's a picture of the author on the back cover, nicely discreet, that most people probably won't notice.

An absolute blast - recommended .
Post A Comment | 3 Comments | | Flag | Link

Gideon Hallett
User: gmh
Date: 2008-02-16 01:45 (UTC)
Subject: (no subject)
The one on the bottom of the back cover?

Yep, we had a slight giggle at that one.

And agreed with regard to HS; the story was excellent, but the background work was also evident - just on a trivial level I kept picking up enjoyable little references to existing MMORGs (such as the reference to character idle animations on p.135) and the like; I'll read it a second time more fully when clanwilliam gives it back.

(I'll leave in-depth discussion of plot etc. to some place where it won't drop massive great spoilers.)
Reply | Thread | Link

Martin Wisse
User: martin_wisse
Date: 2008-02-16 10:57 (UTC)
Subject: (no subject)
I went over to my bookcase to look for that picture as I never noticed it, but then it turned out I had the US edition. Durr.

Loved the book, for the same reasons as you did. One of the few science fiction books with a future that I can see evolving from the present.
Reply | Thread | Link

User: sshi
Date: 2008-02-16 12:00 (UTC)
Subject: (no subject)
I appreciated it mightily, for those reasons, but also because of the absolutely genius pixel-art front cover (marking me as a d-paint veteran, I know :)
Reply | Thread | Link